Tag Archives: House of Representatives

Bad Reasons for Laws: Find Out What’s in the Bill

24 Jan

Wrapping up our series is a reason given for just one bill. It is the most controversial bill in modern history and will be debated for years and years to come. It is the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, otherwise known as Obamacare. Back in 2010 the debate of “health care” reform as the hot political topic. Both the left and the right were battling it out to get public support for their version of reform.

At the time, the Democrats had the majority in both the House of Representatives, 255 to 179, and the Senate, 57 to 41 with 2 independents who caused with the Democrats. While not filibuster proof, all the Democrats needed was three Republicans to join their side to prevent one. The Senate passed their version of the reform bill on December 24, 2009. In March of 2010, shortly before the House was to vote on the Senate version of the bill, Nancy Pelosi, Speaker of the House at the time, gave a  speech at the Legislative Conference for the National Association of Counties[2]. During her speech she made the following statement:

Some argue this one statement was taken out of context. However, Pelosi is not the only one who scoffed at the idea of reading the bill before it was passed. Isn’t that right Mr. John Conyers?

It is easy, at this point, to draw the logical conclusion there were other members of Congress who did not read the bill before voting on it. Instead of being knowledgeable about the proposed legislation which affects all Americans, these people given authority willfully ignore doing their job and just vote as they are told by their party. This could not be any more wrong and insulting.

In the end, their choice cost many of them their elected offices in the 2010 elections as the Republicans took control of the House and gained seats in the Senate. To say it was a lesson learned though would be a stretch at best. While it is unlikely a politician will use the same or similar phrase again, the arrogance and attitude behind the responses seen will likely not change any time soon.

 

References –

  1. Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act – Wikipedia
  2. Pelosi Remarks at the 2010 Legislative Conference for National Association of Counties
Advertisements

So What the Polls are Saying is…

18 Jan

Looking at the Real Clear Politics (RCP) pages for “President Obama Job Approval” [1] and “Direction of Country” [2] the results presented are interestingly confusing. The RCP polls take all the polls for a particular topic, gather their results and compile them into a singular result. It’s one way to get an idea of how those polled across various different means are responding.

The compiled RCP poll results for “President Obama Job Approval” shows President Obama sitting at an approval rating of 52% as of this article. While it went back and forth through out 2012, it started trending upward days before the election and has continued to do through today. If this is one statistic is viewed by itself one might draw the conclusion the majority of people are please with the direction President Obama is leading the country. People wouldn’t approve of a someone leading them in the wrong direction, would they?

Real Clear Politics fortunately has compiled the poll results for “Direction of Country” and it’s not good news for the President at all. According to the RCP poll results around 57% of those polled feel the country is headed in the wrong direction. However, this trend isn’t new. In fact, this has been the case for almost three years. Only in 2009, between April 20th thru June 13th, did the poll trend downward. After June 13th people began to show their dissatisfaction in the direction of the country.

Are these two polls telling us we approve of President Obama leading the country down the wrong direction? Maybe, maybe not. If not then exactly what are the polls telling us then? Quite honestly, not a whole lot. Which is why polls are dismissed by so many people today. The numbers can be spun in an infinite number of ways by both sides to sell their ideology to the masses. To paraphrase the saying by Ben Franklin, there’s lies, damn lies and statistics. We shouldn’t trust any of the three.

In fairness, Congress has maintained a worse rating than the President over the same time-frame. In fact, the RCP “Congressional Job Approval” [3] compiled poll average for the United States House of Representatives and Senate is embarrassing at just over 80%. In other words, while almost 5 out of 10 people disapprove of the job President Obama is doing, 8 out of 10 disapprove of the job the 435 members of Congress is doing.

In the end, we only have ourselves to blame because it is “we the people” who keep sending people we so drastically disapprove of back to do the same job but expect different results. It makes “we the people” fit the definition of insane quite well. Now there’s something to think about.

References:

  1. President Obama Job Approval – Real Clear Politics
  2. Direction of Country – Real Clear Politics
  3. Congressional Job Approval – Real Clear Politics